Back to Resonance Lab

    The Biggest Shift in Search Since Google Itself: What Comes Next for Home Service Contractors

    Search just changed more than it has in 25 years. And most contractors have no idea yet.

    Janette O'Shaughnessy•Founder, Resonating Brands
    October 24, 2026
    10 min read
    The Biggest Shift in Search Since Google Itself: What Comes Next for Home Service Contractors

    Search just changed more than it has in 25 years. And most contractors have no idea yet.

    This one is for roofers, HVAC companies, tree services, plumbers, cleaners, and every home service owner who depends on the phone ringing. Phil Risher called it "the biggest shift in search since Google itself". He's right. I want to go a step further. Here is what changed, what is most likely coming next, and what you should do about it now.

    What actually changed

    In May 2026, at its I/O conference, Google rebuilt Search around AI. Google itself called the new search box "the biggest upgrade to Search in more than 25 years."

    Here is what that means in plain English:

    •The search box got smarter. People now type full questions, not three words. "Who can fix a leaking skylight in Holland this week and what will it cost?" is a normal search now.

    •Google answers first. AI Overviews reach more than 2.5 billion people a month. AI Mode, the chat-style version of Google, has more than 1 billion monthly users.

    •Google builds the answer on the fly. Instead of ten blue links, Search can now create custom comparisons, charts, and tools right on the page.

    •Google runs errands in the background. New "information agents" watch the web 24/7 for a user and send an alert when something matches what they want.

    •Google picks up the phone. This is the big one for the trades. Google said that for select categories like home repair, beauty, and pet care, people can ask Google to call businesses on their behalf. It is rolling out across the U.S.

    Read that last one again. A homeowner can say, "Find me three roofers who can look at storm damage this week." Google's AI calls local contractors, asks about price and availability, and lays the answers side by side. The homeowner picks one. The homeowner never dialed a number.

    Why this is bigger than anything since Google itself

    For 25 years, the game was simple. Rank on page one. Get the click. Win the call.

    That game is ending.

    An Ahrefs study of 300,000 keywords found that when an AI Overview shows up, the number-one result gets about 58% fewer clicks than it would have otherwise. Position two loses about half. You can rank first and still lose the customer, because Google already answered the question.

    So the question is no longer "Do I rank?" The question is now:

    When the AI builds its short list, are you on it?

    That is the shift. Search used to send people to you. Now, more and more, the AI decides for them and only shows them the winner. Forbes put it well: the contest is moving from page rankings to "agent selection."

    What is most likely coming next

    Nobody has a crystal ball. But I build websites and search systems for contractors every day, and the direction is clear. Here is my bet on what happens over the next 12 to 24 months.

    1. The AI will call you before the customer does

    Google has been testing this for over a year under the name "Ask for Me." It started with auto repair shops and nail salons. Home repair is next. Expect it to spread from "find me a price" to "book me the appointment."

    Here is the part that should keep you up at night. If Google's AI calls your shop and nobody answers, it doesn't leave a message and wait. It calls the next company on the list. You will never know that lead existed.

    Speed-to-lead used to mean answering a homeowner fast. Now it means answering a robot fast, too. Every missed call is a job handed to your competitor. If you are not answering every call during business hours, and capturing after-hours calls with a voice agent, you will lose jobs you never see. (More on this in AI voice agents and capturing more leads.)

    2. Your prices and availability become ranking factors

    When the AI calls, it is asking two things: how much, and how soon. Homeowners asking AI questions are asking the same things.

    The contractors who publish clear starting prices, price ranges, service areas, and booking options online give the AI what it needs to recommend them. The ones who hide everything behind "call for a free quote" give the AI nothing to work with.

    I expect this to go further. Real-time availability, online booking, and instant estimates will move from "nice to have" to "the reason you got picked."

    3. Booking will happen inside Google

    Today, AI can find you and compare you. Next, it will book you. Google already showed agentic booking on stage. Forbes describes the direction plainly: an agent that finds, compares, and books for the user.

    When that arrives for home services, the customer may never visit your website before they're on your calendar. That means your booking system, your Google Business Profile, and your website all need to be connected and accurate. A booking link that goes to a dead form will cost you money.

    4. Your website becomes the source of truth for machines

    Some people will hear all this and say, "So websites don't matter anymore." That is exactly wrong.

    The AI has to get its facts from somewhere. It reads your website, your Google Business Profile, your reviews, and what other sites say about you. Your website is the one place you fully control. It is where the AI learns who you are, what you do, where you work, what it costs, and why you're the right choice.

    That only works if the AI can read it. That means:

    •Schema markup that tells machines your services, service areas, hours, reviews, and FAQs

    •Fast pages that load for crawlers as well as people

    •Real answers on the page, not marketing fluff

    •Service area pages that prove you work in each town

    A pretty brochure site won't cut it. This is exactly why we build next generation websites. They are built to be read by Google, ChatGPT, Gemini, Perplexity, and Claude as well as by homeowners. (See why your business still needs a website in the age of AI.)

    5. Fewer clicks, but better ones

    Your website traffic will most likely go down. Don't panic when it does.

    The people who still click through after the AI has done their research are further along. They've already compared. They've already read your reviews. They're ready to call. Expect lower traffic and higher-quality leads. Judge your website by calls, forms, and booked jobs, not by visitor counts.

    6. Background agents will watch for you

    Google's new information agents run 24/7 and alert users when something changes. Picture a homeowner who tells Google, "Let me know when a top-rated HVAC company near me has a fall tune-up special."

    The contractors who post fresh offers, seasonal updates, Google Business Profile posts, and new project photos give those agents something to find. The ones who haven't touched their profile since 2022 stay invisible. Freshness is going to matter more, not less.

    7. Reviews get read by machines, not just people

    The AI doesn't just count stars. It reads what reviews say, and how recent they are. A review that says "replaced our roof in Zeeland after the hail storm, crew cleaned up every nail" tells the AI where you work, what you do, and how you do it.

    Expect recent, detailed reviews to carry more weight than a big pile of old five-star ratings. If your best reviews are from three years ago, you have work to do. (See why your 300 reviews from 2022 aren't selling for you anymore.)

    8. Ads will move inside the AI answer

    Google makes its money on ads. Ads are already showing up inside AI Overviews and AI Mode. Expect more of that, and expect it to get more expensive as the space shrinks. Paid ads will still work. But the contractors who earn their spot in the AI answer will pay far less per job than the ones who only rent it.

    What stays the same

    Here is the good news. The fundamentals didn't change. They got more important.

    AI recommends the companies with the most proof. Real reviews. Real job photos. Real service area coverage. Real answers to real homeowner questions. A Google Business Profile that's complete and active. A phone that gets answered.

    Google rewards proof, not promises. So does every AI.

    The companies showing up in AI answers are not always the biggest. They are the ones that did the work.

    Your action plan: what to do now

    You don't need to do all of this tomorrow. But you need to start. Here's the order I'd tackle it in.

    1.Answer every call. Stop letting calls go to a full voicemail box. Add a voice agent or answering service for after hours and overflow. Google's AI will not wait for you.

    2.Ask the AI about yourself. Open ChatGPT, Gemini, and Google AI Mode. Ask, "Who is the best [your trade] in [your town]?" See who gets named. Then ask why. That tells you what the AI trusts.

    3.Publish your basics. Starting prices or price ranges, service areas, hours, warranty terms, and how fast you can get out. Put them on your website in plain language.

    4.Fix your schema markup. Your site should tell machines your business type, services, service areas, reviews, and FAQs. If you don't know whether yours does, it probably doesn't.

    5.Build out your service area pages. One real page for each town you serve, with local job photos and local proof. (See service area pages that rank.)

    6.Keep your Google Business Profile fresh. Weekly photos, regular posts, correct categories, fast replies to reviews.

    7.Get recent, detailed reviews. Ask every happy customer. Ask them to mention the town and the job.

    8.Make booking easy. Online scheduling or a fast quote request that actually reaches someone. Test it yourself this week.

    9.Measure what matters. Track calls, form fills, and booked jobs. Stop judging your site by traffic alone.

    Frequently asked questions

    What is the biggest change in Google search in 2026?

    Google rebuilt Search around AI. It now answers questions directly with AI Overviews and AI Mode, builds custom results on the page, runs background agents for users, and in categories like home repair can call local businesses on a customer's behalf to ask about pricing and availability.

    Is Google's AI really calling contractors?

    Yes. Google has tested AI calling under the name "Ask for Me" since early 2025, starting with auto repair and nail salons. In May 2026, Google announced it is expanding to home repair, beauty, and pet care across the U.S. The AI asks about pricing and availability and reports back to the customer.

    What happens if I miss a call from Google's AI?

    The AI moves on to the next business on its list. You are not notified, so you will never know you lost the lead. That is why answering every call, or using a voice agent for overflow and after hours, matters more now than ever.

    Does SEO still matter if Google gives AI answers?

    Yes. The AI pulls its answers from websites, Google Business Profiles, and reviews. SEO now works alongside AEO (Answer Engine Optimization, for ChatGPT, Gemini, Perplexity, and Claude) and GEO (Generative Engine Optimization, for Google's AI Overviews). You need all three.

    Will my website traffic go down?

    Probably. AI answers reduce clicks. One Ahrefs study found the top result gets about 58% fewer clicks when an AI Overview appears. But the visitors who still click are further along and more ready to hire. Measure calls and booked jobs, not just traffic.

    What should a home service contractor do first?

    Make sure every call gets answered. Then publish clear pricing ranges, service areas, and hours on your website, add schema markup, and keep your Google Business Profile and reviews fresh.

    The bottom line

    The shift is here. Homeowners are asking AI who to hire, and AI is making the short list for them. Sometimes it is even making the call.

    There has never been a better time to get ahead of it. Most of your competitors haven't noticed yet.

    Want to know if the AI can find you? Contact Resonating Brands and we'll show you exactly how your business shows up in Google, ChatGPT, and AI search today, and what it will take to get on the short list.

    Sources

    •Phil Risher, "The Biggest Shift in Search Since Google Itself", LinkedIn

    •TechCrunch, "Google Search as you know it is over", May 19, 2026

    •Forbes, "Google Wants Search To Stop Answering And Start Acting", May 20, 2026

    •Ahrefs, "AI Overviews Reduce Clicks"

    Ready to Implement This Strategy?

    Let our team build the digital growth system that puts these insights into action.

    Book Your Strategy Call

    About the Author

    Janette O'Shaughnessy

    Janette O'Shaughnessy is the founder of Resonating Brands, a digital marketing and web design agency specializing in next generation websites and lead generation systems for roofing contractors and home service businesses. She helps roofing, plumbing, electrical, hvac, and tree service companies move beyond outdated websites and into next generation digital infrastructure built for the way homeowners search today.

    Related Articles