In 2023, a Texas roofer named Brad Stilley woke up to 300 one-star reviews on his Google Business Profile. Not 3. Not 30. Three hundred. Around the same time, a Florida roofing owner named Jeff Arnold watched his profile get hit with a wave of fake negative reviews — and then got messages demanding payment to make them stop. That's not a horror story from 2010. That is the industry we work in right now.
If you own a roofing company, fake Google reviews are not a question of *if* — they are a question of *when*. Competitors do it. Ex-employees do it. Extortion scams do it. AI-generated review farms do it. And because roofing is a high-ticket, trust-based purchase where homeowners check reviews before they call, a single cluster of fake 1-stars can cost you tens of thousands of dollars in lost jobs before Google gets around to addressing them.
The good news: you have more options than you think, and most roofers who handle this right end up stronger on the other side. I've walked several roofing clients through this process. Here is exactly how to handle it.
Why Roofing Companies Are a Prime Target
Roofing attracts fake reviews more than almost any other home service vertical. There are four reasons worth understanding, because your response strategy depends on knowing who is attacking you.
•Unethical competitors.: A roofer two towns over sees you outranking them on Google Maps. A handful of 1-star reviews is the cheapest way to knock you off page one. This happens more than anyone in the industry wants to admit.
•Storm-chaser retaliation.: You tell a homeowner not to sign the assignment of benefits with the out-of-state roofer who just knocked on their door. The homeowner listens. The storm chaser loses the job. Two days later, you have a fake 1-star review.
•Extortion schemes.: A wave of negative reviews shows up on your profile — followed by a message from a random email offering to make them disappear for a few hundred dollars. This is organized. This is a business model. Do not pay them. Paying them guarantees you'll be hit again.
•Disgruntled ex-employees.: The salesman you fired for inflating insurance claims? He now has six Google accounts and a lot of free time.
Knowing the source matters, because the evidence you build and the angle you report under depends on it.
What Counts as a "Fake" Review in Google's Eyes
Before you flag anything, understand this: Google does not remove a review just because you disagree with it. A legitimate customer who is unhappy with your work has every right to say so, and trying to game Google into removing honest criticism will damage your profile's trust signals long-term. Don't do it.
Google removes reviews that violate their content policies. For roofers, the categories that almost always qualify are:
•Fake content.: The reviewer was never your customer. They did not hire you, inspect with you, or interact with your company in any way.
•Conflict of interest.: The reviewer is a competitor, a former employee, or someone with a financial interest in hurting your business.
•Spam.: Bot-generated content, paid review-farm output, or mass-posted text.
•Off-topic.: Political rants, personal grievances unrelated to the roofing service you provided, or reviews that are really about a different company.
•Harassment or hate speech.: Personal attacks, profanity aimed at an employee, or discriminatory language.
•Defamation.: False claims that you committed illegal acts — insurance fraud, theft, unlicensed work you aren't doing, etc.
If the review fits one of these buckets, you have a legitimate case for removal. If it doesn't — if it's just a mad homeowner who feels you overcharged — your strategy is a professional public response, not a removal attempt.
Red Flags: How to Spot a Fake Review on Your Roofing Profile
Before you report, verify. Google's automated system is suspicious of business owners who flag reviews without cause, and repeat flags that get denied weaken future appeals. Here is the checklist I run through with every client review dispute.
•The reviewer is not in your records.: Search your CRM, JobNimbus, AccuLynx, CompanyCam, your QuickBooks invoices, your inspection log, and your email. If the name does not appear anywhere — and your crew doesn't recognize it — that is your first strong signal.
•The account is brand new or nearly empty.: Click the reviewer's name. If their Google account was created last week, or if this review is their only review, or if they have a generic avatar with no photo, your suspicion level goes up.
•The profile has a suspicious review history.: Some fake accounts are reused. You may find the same person has left 1-star reviews at six other roofing companies — often in different states. That pattern alone is powerful evidence.
•The language is vague and generic.: Real unhappy customers name the crew chief. They describe the day of the job. They mention the shingle color, the gutter, the chimney. Fake reviews say things like "worst roofer ever" and "do not use" with zero specifics.
•The review mentions services you don't offer.: If someone leaves you a 1-star review complaining about your solar panel install and you don't install solar panels, that is a conflict of interest signal — they're reviewing the wrong company on purpose.
•The timing is suspicious.: Multiple 1-stars in a cluster, often within hours of each other. Reviews that show up right after you won a bid against a specific competitor. Reviews timed with an active storm market.
Two or three of these signals together is usually enough to move forward with a report.
Step-by-Step: How to Actually Report a Fake Review
Here is the exact process. Do not skip steps. Do not try just one reporting channel and call it done — using multiple channels in parallel roughly triples your removal rate.
1.Document before you do anything else. — Take screenshots of the review, the star rating, the date, the reviewer's profile, any other reviews they've posted, and the full text of the review. Do this first. If the reviewer edits or deletes the review mid-process, you need the original in your records.
2.Flag through Google Business Profile. — Log into your Business Profile at business.google.com. Click Reviews. Find the fake review, click the three dots, and select "Flag as inappropriate." Choose the category that fits (Spam, Off-topic, Conflict of Interest, Harassment, etc.) and submit.
3.Flag through Google Maps as a second channel. — Open Google Maps. Navigate to your business. Find the review. Click the three dots. Flag it there too. This is a separate intake queue. Yes, it counts.
4.Use the Google Reviews Management Tool. — This is the tool most roofers don't know exists. It lives at support.google.com/business and is where you report reviews directly to Google's review team, track the status of anything you've flagged, and submit appeals on denied reports. This is the only channel that gives you visibility into what Google is doing with your report.
5.Contact Google Business Profile Support directly. — If you're dealing with something coordinated — a review bomb, an extortion scheme, a pattern of attacks — go beyond the automated flag. Google Business Profile Support has humans. You can reach them through the Help section of your Business Profile dashboard. Be specific, professional, and bring evidence.
6.Post in the Google Business Profile Help Community. — For high-volume attacks, publicly posting a clear, evidence-backed description of what's happening on the Help Community forum sometimes gets a Product Expert or Google employee to step in. Do not post customer private information or inflammatory language. Be factual.
Expect the process to take anywhere from a few days to several weeks. Google says 5–20 business days. For coordinated attacks, plan on 2–3 months.
The Evidence Packet That Actually Gets Fake Reviews Removed
This is the part most articles skip, and it is the single most important thing I can tell you. Google will not take your word for it. Flags with no backing evidence are denied at an astonishing rate — industry data suggests fewer than 1 in 5 flagged reviews gets removed on the first attempt without supporting documentation.
Here is what you need to build a proof packet that actually works.
•Your customer database export.: A clean search of your CRM showing zero records matching the reviewer's name, email, or phone number. Screenshot it.
•Screenshots of the reviewer's profile.: Their account age, their other reviews, their avatar. If they've hit other roofers, document those reviews too. A grid of screenshots showing the same account attacking multiple companies is compelling evidence.
•Cross-referenced attack patterns.: This is what Brad Stilley used to get 300 fake reviews wiped. He built a PDF showing that the same accounts attacking his business were also attacking other roofers across the country. That pattern proved it was organized — not just unhappy individual customers — and Google removed the reviews three months after he submitted the report.
•Communications from extortionists.: If anyone has emailed or messaged you demanding payment to remove reviews, that is a massive piece of evidence. Screenshot the message, the sender's info, and the timing relative to the review wave. This turns a content dispute into a coordinated bad-faith attack, which Google takes much more seriously.
•Documentation of your real service area.: For reviews that appear to come from far outside where you work, a map or list showing your actual coverage area helps prove the reviewer could not have hired you.
Package all of this into a single PDF. Reference it in your reports. Upload it when the Reviews Management Tool or support channel lets you. The difference between a bare flag and a documented report is night and day.
Respond Publicly While You're Fighting for Removal
This part is non-negotiable. While Google is reviewing your report, every homeowner who visits your profile can see the fake review sitting there unanswered. Silence signals that the review is true. A professional response signals the opposite.
Here is the voice to use: calm, factual, brief. Do not be defensive. Do not match energy. Do not accuse.
> Thank you for reaching out. We searched our customer records and we do not have any record of providing service to anyone by this name. We take every review seriously, so if there has been a misunderstanding or you meant to review a different company, please contact us directly at [phone] and we will be glad to help sort it out.
That's it. That response does three things at once: it tells Google you've investigated, it tells future homeowners that you are professional and calm under pressure, and it puts the burden back on the reviewer to either clarify or disappear.
What you should never do: argue with the reviewer, threaten legal action publicly, reveal private customer information, or respond in all caps. Every one of those makes you look worse than the fake review does.
The FTC Consumer Review Rule (And What It Means for You)
This is the part most roofing content does not cover, and it matters.
On October 21, 2024, a new FTC rule went into effect that makes buying, selling, or disseminating fake reviews a federal violation. The civil penalty is now up to $53,088 per violation. That applies to competitors who buy fake negative reviews about your business, review brokers who sell them, and any business that procures them. The FTC issued its first enforcement warning letters in December 2025, and enforcement is ramping up.
For roofers, this changes the calculus in two ways.
First, if you catch a competitor buying fake reviews against you and you have evidence — screenshots, messaging, paid-review broker involvement — you can file a complaint at reportfraud.ftc.gov. You cannot personally sue under the FTC rule, but the FTC itself can, and complaints from affected businesses drive enforcement priorities.
Second, it should make you check your own house. If anyone on your team has ever incentivized a 5-star review, bought reviews from a reputation service that generates them, or leaned on employees to review the company without disclosing they work there, you are exposed. Fix that now. The FTC rule applies to positive fake reviews just as much as negative ones.
When to Bring in a Lawyer
Most fake-review situations do not need legal action. Google's removal process works, it just takes time. But there are three scenarios where you should pick up the phone and call an attorney.
•Extortion.: If anyone is demanding payment to remove reviews, that is a crime. An attorney can help you document it, report it to law enforcement, and in some cases pursue the extortionists directly.
•Defamation.: If a review makes a specific, false factual claim that damages your business — "this company stole my deductible," "they did uninsured work," "they fraudulently billed my insurance" — and none of it is true, you may have a defamation claim. A court order can compel Google to remove a review that's been legally adjudicated as defamatory, even if Google's own review team declined to remove it.
•Coordinated competitor attacks.: If you have clear evidence that a specific competitor is behind a sustained fake review campaign, there are civil remedies under unfair business practice laws in most states, and the new FTC rule adds federal exposure. A cease-and-desist letter from your attorney often ends the attacks immediately.
Use a local business attorney who understands online reputation and defamation law. Most will do a 30-minute consult for free or flat-rate.
Prevention: Build a Review Moat So Fakes Can't Sink You
The best defense against fake reviews is not the removal process — it's volume and velocity. If your profile has 400 real reviews with a 4.9 average, six fake 1-stars barely move the needle. If your profile has 23 reviews and a 4.6 average, six fake 1-stars are catastrophic.
Here is the prevention stack I recommend for every roofing client.
•Automate review requests the day the job is finished.: Not a week later. Not when the crew chief remembers. The day of completion, an automated text and email goes out asking the homeowner to leave a Google review, with a direct link to your review form. Response rates are dramatically higher at 24 hours than at 7 days.
•Pre-qualify before you ask.: A two-question satisfaction check first ("How did we do?" 1–5) routes happy customers to Google and gives unhappy customers a private feedback channel instead. This is legal as long as you are not suppressing reviews — you are simply asking for reviews from satisfied customers, which is explicitly allowed.
•Diversify your review presence.: Google matters most, but the Better Business Bureau is increasingly cited in AI Overviews, Yelp still carries weight, and Facebook recommendations still influence homeowners. Build a presence across all four so a single platform attack doesn't take you down.
•Monitor daily.: Set up Google alerts for your business name. Check your Business Profile review feed every morning. The faster you catch a fake review, the stronger your evidence packet will be and the less time it will spend in front of potential customers.
•Respond to every real review.: Fake or real, positive or negative, every review gets a response within 24 hours. This is both a ranking signal for Google and a trust signal for homeowners reading your profile. It also trains Google's system to see you as an actively managed, legitimate business, which makes your flags more credible.
For more on building reputation systems that scale, see our guide on Google Business Profile Posts: What Roofers Should Post and How Often.
The Bottom Line
Fake Google reviews are an industry reality, not an industry exception. The roofers who handle them well treat fake reviews like any other operational risk: monitor for them, document evidence, report through multiple channels, respond professionally in public, and build enough real-review volume that a handful of bad-faith attacks do not sink the boat.
If your company is actively being attacked right now and you are not sure how to move, don't wait. The earlier you start building your evidence packet, the faster Google removes the reviews, and the less revenue you lose to homeowners who clicked away before you could respond.
Janette O'Shaughnessy is the founder of Resonating Brands, a boutique digital marketing agency based in West Michigan that builds [next generation websites](/services/next-generation-websites), voice agents, and lead generation systems for roofing contractors and home service companies.
Continue Learning: Roofing Marketing Hub · Google Business Profile Setup · Google Business Profile Posts · Local SEO for Roofers
